The short answer
On November 10, 2026, FDA published two final orders that change the U.S. color additive rules. Both take effect on January 11, 2027. From that date:
- Methylene chloride, ethylene dichloride and trichloroethylene may no longer be used as extraction solvents to make annatto extract, paprika oleoresin or turmeric oleoresin used as colors.
- Methylene chloride may no longer be used as a diluent in inks for marking fruit and vegetables.
FDA says that, after these orders, the three solvents have no remaining authorized uses as color additives or in making color additives. The industry says it stopped using them years ago, so most exporters will not need to change anything. But you should confirm it in writing with your color supplier before January 11, 2027.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Documents | Two FDA final orders: 91 FR 72410 (FR Doc. 2026-22866) and 91 FR 72413 (FR Doc. 2026-22865) |
| Published | November 10, 2026 (FDA announced them on November 9, 2026) |
| Effective date | January 11, 2027 |
| Objections | Objections and requests for a hearing are due December 10, 2026 (dockets FDA-2026-C-3071 and FDA-2023-C-5679) |
| Who is affected | Makers of annatto, paprika and turmeric colors; food, cosmetic and drug brands that use annatto, paprika or turmeric colors; fresh produce packers that mark fruit or vegetables with ink |
What exactly changes
Both orders amend 21 CFR part 73, the list of color additives that do not need FDA batch certification. Here is each change:
| Color additive | Regulation | Removed | FDA's reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annatto extract | 21 CFR 73.30(a)(1)(ii) | Ethylene dichloride, methylene chloride, trichloroethylene (extraction solvents) | Use abandoned by industry |
| Paprika oleoresin | 21 CFR 73.345(a)(1) | The same three solvents | Use abandoned by industry |
| Turmeric oleoresin | 21 CFR 73.615(a)(1) | The same three solvents | Use abandoned by industry |
| Inks for marking fruit and vegetables | 21 CFR 73.1(b)(1)(ii) | Methylene chloride (diluent) | Delaney Clause: it causes cancer in laboratory animals |
The other solvents in these lists stay. For example, acetone and hexane remain permitted for annatto extract and turmeric oleoresin. The colors themselves are still approved. Only the three solvents are removed.
Why there are two orders with two different reasons
FDA received two separate petitions:
- Industry petition (CAP 5C0340) from the International Association of Color Manufacturers. It asked FDA to remove the three solvents because nobody uses them anymore. The petitioner surveyed 44 companies and 3 trade associations (representing about 375 more companies), and all confirmed they no longer use these solvents. FDA received no comments showing current use, so it granted this request on the basis of abandonment.
- Consumer and environmental groups’ petition (CAP 4C0327) led by the Environmental Defense Fund. It asked FDA to remove the solvents under the Delaney Clause, the part of the law that bans color additives found to cause cancer in people or animals. FDA agreed for methylene chloride in fruit and vegetable marking inks, because there it is part of the color additive mixture itself.
FDA did not use the Delaney Clause for the extraction solvents. In FDA’s view, solvent left in annatto, paprika or turmeric colors is an impurity, and the Delaney Clause applies to color additives, not to their impurities. The result is the same for exporters: from January 11, 2027 the solvents are not allowed for any of these uses.
Does this affect your products?
Check your products if any of these apply:
- Color makers who extract annatto, paprika or turmeric colors — for example oleoresin producers in India, annatto processors in Brazil, or color suppliers in China.
- Food brands that use these colors in snacks, cheese, sauces, seasonings, baked goods, dairy desserts or drinks. For how colors are declared, see our guide to special US label declarations.
- Cosmetic brands that use annatto in lipsticks, soaps or creams — see FDA color additive rules for makeup.
- Fresh produce packers — for example in Mexico — that print codes or logos directly on fruit or vegetables with ink.
These two orders change the color additive rules in 21 CFR part 73 only. If you sell paprika or turmeric oleoresin as a flavoring or spice, ask your adviser which other rules apply to your product; our spice exporter guide covers the basics.
Example: a seasoning maker in India
An Indian factory makes a snack seasoning for a U.S. importer. It uses paprika oleoresin and turmeric oleoresin for color, bought from a local extractor. Before January 11, 2027, the factory asks the extractor for a signed statement listing the solvents used, and adds “no methylene chloride, ethylene dichloride or trichloroethylene” to its purchase specification. The U.S. importer files this statement with its FSVP records for the supplier.
What happens if a product does not comply
From January 11, 2027, a color made with one of these solvents is no longer an approved color for that use. A food or cosmetic containing it can be detained and refused at the U.S. border. FDA already uses Import Alert 45-02 for foods with illegal or undeclared colors, and it updated that alert on November 12, 2026. See FDA import alerts explained for how these alerts work.
The orders do not set a separate sell-through period for products made before the effective date. The safest plan is to make sure every product shipped to the U.S. uses colors made without these solvents now.
Checklist for exporters and importers
- 1List every color in your U.S. productsFind each product that contains annatto, paprika or turmeric color, and each fruit or vegetable you mark with ink.
- 2Ask your supplier in writingGet a signed statement or specification sheet listing the extraction solvents (or ink diluents) used.
- 3Update your specificationsAdd the three solvents as “not permitted” in purchase specs and supplier contracts.
- 4Update FSVP and supplier recordsU.S. importers should add the supplier statement to their FSVP file and review it in the next supplier evaluation.
- 5Check cosmetics tooBrands using annatto in cosmetics should ask their color supplier the same question.
- 6Decide on objections by December 10, 2026Only relevant if you still depend on one of these solvents. Objections go to the dockets on regulations.gov.
Our FSVP compliance audit and gap assessment ($250) reviews supplier verification records, including color and additive specifications. FSVP program development from $400.
🏢 No U.S. company to act as FSVP importer? Orionex offers an FSVP importer service for food and dietary supplements — from $80 per shipment, with the program and Qualified Individual included.
Frequently asked questions
When does the solvent ban for annatto, paprika and turmeric colors take effect?
January 11, 2027. Objections and requests for a hearing are due December 10, 2026. If valid objections stay any part of the orders, FDA will publish a notice in the Federal Register.
Can I still use annatto, paprika and turmeric colors in the US?
Yes. The colors stay approved. Only three extraction solvents are removed: methylene chloride, ethylene dichloride and trichloroethylene. Other listed solvents, such as acetone and hexane, remain permitted.
Does this change affect cosmetics?
Yes, for annatto. The cosmetic and drug annatto rules (21 CFR 73.2030 and 73.1030) refer to the food rule in 21 CFR 73.30, so the three solvents are no longer authorized there either.
What changes for fruit and vegetable marking inks?
Methylene chloride is removed as a diluent in inks for marking fruit and vegetables (21 CFR 73.1(b)(1)(ii)), under the Delaney Clause, from January 11, 2027.
Do I need to change my label?
No. The orders only change which solvents may be used to make these colors. They do not change how the colors are declared on the label.
Sources
- Federal Register — Color additive petition from the International Association of Color Manufacturers; final order, 91 FR 72410, FR Doc. 2026-22866 (November 10, 2026)
- Federal Register — Color additive petition from Environmental Defense Fund et al.; final order, 91 FR 72413, FR Doc. 2026-22865 (November 10, 2026)
- GovInfo — Federal Register Vol. 91, No. 216, November 10, 2026 (pages 72410–72419)
- FDA — Constituent update: FDA to revoke authorizations for uses of certain substances as color additives or in the production of color additives (November 9, 2026)
- eCFR — 21 CFR part 73, Listing of color additives exempt from certification (§§ 73.1, 73.30, 73.345, 73.615, 73.1030, 73.2030)
- Federal Register — Revocation of the color additive listing for Orange B on casings or surfaces of frankfurters; confirmation of effective date, FR Doc. 2026-23112 (November 13, 2026)
- FDA — Import Alert 45-02 (foods containing illegal and/or undeclared colors), revised November 12, 2026
Dates, fees and regulation numbers checked against FDA and Federal Register sources on November 16, 2026. This article is general information, not legal advice.